Vintage watch papers: Do papers really matter?

In this Set Back in Time post, we discuss a question common amongst vintage watch collectors: “Should I buy a vintage watch with its original papers?” It’s a fair question, and one worth exploring. After all, owning a piece of history is special, but does a bit of extra paperwork really make the difference? The question to ask is, “Do vintage watch papers really matter?”

Box, papers, box and papers, or full set

When shopping for a vintage watch, you’ll often hear or read the terms box, papers, or full set being thrown around. But what do they actually mean? Let’s chat about these extras and why they matter when it comes to owning a vintage timepiece.

The basics

When we talk about “papers” we are discussing the original accessories that came with the watch when it was first sold. These can include the box, papers (certificates, guarantees and receipts), or the whole bundle, often referred to as a “full set”. Accessories can also include bracelet links, tools, manuals, and tags.

The availability of these extras depends on the age and type of the watch. Older watches, understandably, are less likely to come with all their original bits and pieces. But when they do, it can add to the watch’s value and appeal. Collectors love a more “complete” package, and accessories can help with the authenticity of a vintage watch.

Boxes: nice, but not essential

An original watch box is a lovely addition, but it doesn’t carry the same weight as other accessories. Why? Boxes, while sometimes unique, are often generic or period-correct. This means they don’t have a specific connection to a single watch. This also means there is not a 100% guarantee the box is original, it could be a period replacement.

If you’re determined to have the original box, the good news is it’s usually possible to find one that fits the era of your watch. It might take a bit of searching, but it’s far from impossible. For this reason, boxes tend to have a smaller impact on a watch’s value compared to other extras.

Papers: the real deal

When people say “papers,” they usually mean certificates or documents that originally came with the watch. These are much more significant than boxes because they contain details that directly link the paperwork to the watch. Most importantly, they include the watch’s unique serial number, which proves authenticity and origin.

Unlike boxes, papers can’t easily be replaced or sourced later, unless, of course, they’re forged. Unfortunately, forgeries exist, so always check the legitimacy of any papers and trust your seller. Between a watch with just a box and one with only papers, the latter is typically more desirable. Papers offer that extra layer of authenticity, which is highly valued in the vintage watch world.

The full set: a collector’s dream

The ultimate prize for many collectors is the full set. This means everything that originally came with the watch is still intact. Think of the box, papers, booklet, tags, certificate, outer box, and sometimes even the receipt or warranty card. Service receipts throughout the life of the watch add an extra layer of authenticity.

Smiths De Luxe, the "Full set".
Smiths De Luxe, the “Full set”.

A full set tells the entire story of the watch, from its original sale to its current state. It’s rare, it’s complete, and it’s often the most expensive option. However, for those who appreciate the details and history of vintage timepieces, it’s hard to beat.

Accessories summary

Is summary:

  • Box: A box to have but doesn’t hold much value on its own.
  • Papers: A significant addition that confirms authenticity and links directly to the watch.
  • Accessories: Includes spare links, tools, manuals, and retail tags.
  • Full Set: The complete package that’s highly collectable and commands a premium price.

Authenticity

The appeal of vintage watch papers often lies in their connection to authenticity. They’re like a birth certificate for your timepiece, offering a glimpse into its origins. However, in today’s world, papers don’t always guarantee what they seem. Believe it or not, there are fake watches out there paired with fake papers. Even worse, some dodgy sellers match counterfeit watches with genuine papers to create the illusion of authenticity. This is why It is important to trust your seller. If you’re working with someone reputable, you’re already ahead. If you’re feeling uneasy about the purchase, trust your instinct and walk away. Peace of mind beats counterfeit paperwork every time.

What’s the price of those papers?

A watch with vintage papers will cost more. A lot more. While it’s great to have that “full set,” you’re essentially paying for something that might spend most of its life in a drawer or safe. Knowing it’s there is satisfying, but will you pull it out regularly to admire it? Probably not.

When you eventually sell the watch, it will sell for more because of the papers. However, you had already paid a premium when you bought it. This becomes a bit of a balancing act. You’re not necessarily making more money, you’re just maintaining the value of your investment.

Investment: should papers influence your decision?

If you’re buying a vintage watch purely as an investment, papers can add a layer of desirability. Collectors often gravitate towards a “full set”, which means the watch, original box, and all accompanying paperwork. It’s like buying a classic car with its original manual and toolkit, a bonus on top that adds charm.

That said, it’s not a dealbreaker for every collector. Most prefer to focus on the watch itself. After all, it’s the craftsmanship, history, and style that matter most. Vintage watch papers are nice, but they’re not the be-all and end-all.

The reality of owning papers

What happens after you buy that watch with its vintage papers? Where do they go? Most likely, they’ll sit in a drawer, box, or safe, gathering dust. That’s not to say they’re pointless. Knowing you’ve got the full set can give you a quiet sense of satisfaction. It’s just not something you’ll interact with daily.

On the other side, papers can make reselling easier. They’re like a stamp of approval, making your watch more attractive to future buyers. But remember, it’s a double-edged sword. If you lose them, the value can drop significantly. Keeping track of those papers becomes its own responsibility.

Will papers make you happy?

At the end of the day, it’s all about what you value. Some collectors love the idea of a full set. It’s a complete story, a finished puzzle. Others couldn’t care less. They’re in it for the watch itself, the feel, the history, the joy of wearing it.

Think about your priorities. Do vintage watch papers bring you happiness, or are they just an expensive afterthought? There’s no right or wrong answer here. It’s your watch collecting hobby, and therefore, your rules.

Summary

Are vintage watch papers worth it? The answer depends on what matters to you. They’re lovely to have, but they’re not the be-all and end-all of owning a vintage watch. If authenticity is your main concern, focus on buying from a trustworthy source. If you’re a collector who loves a complete package, go for it. Just remember, papers are a bonus, not a necessity.

Admittedly, at Set Back in Time, we aren’t too fussed about the “full set”. Yes, we have a small number of watches across our collections that qualify, or perhaps may just have an original box, but the vast majority don’t. Our focus is really on the originality of the watch itself, that is challenging on its own.

In the world of vintage watches, the watch itself is the star of the show. Papers? They’re the supporting cast. Nice to have, but the story can still shine without them. So, whether you’re hunting down your next piece or just dreaming of one, enjoy the process. After all, it’s the love of the watch that truly matters.

Related content

How to authenticate a vintage watch: a collector’s guide.

Do The Box And Papers Matter When Buying A Pre-Owned/Vintage Watch? at Fratello.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *